What Knewton Does—and Doesn't—Know

Enterprises

What Knewton Does—and Doesn't—Know

Oct 17, 2015

TRUE OR FALSE: Fascinating NPR story this week about Knewton—and accompanying commentary by industry watcher Michael Feldstein.

Knewton has been one of the most vocal advocates of aggressive adaptive learning, namely a scenario where the software monitors every click of a student's mouse to assess how well he or she understands a topic, with the goal of delivering "just the right" content.

Killer quotes:

From Knewton founder and CEO Jose Ferreira: "We think of it [Knewton] like a robot tutor in the sky that can semi-read your mind and figure out what your strengths and weaknesses are, down to the percentile."

From Michael Feldstein, a consultant and cofounder of ed blog, e-Literate: "He is overselling the kind of power that Knewton can do...I would go so far as to say that he is selling snake oil."

Ferreira has a history of making claims and announcements that don't quite turn out the way he predicts. One example: in 2012, Ferreira had announced with some fanfare a project to deliver Knewton’s technology to incarcerated youth. In January of this year, in answer to a question from EdSurge, Ferreira conceded that the project never got started—that “bigger opportunities” with partner Houghton Mifflin had superceded the project.

As Feldstein writes: "If you want to sell me a product that helps students to learn, then don’t insult my intelligence. Explain what the damned thing does in clear, concrete, and straightforward language, with real-world examples when possible."

Here, here.

Learn more about EdSurge operations, ethics and policies here. Learn more about EdSurge supporters here.

More from EdSurge

Get our email newsletterSign me up
Keep up to date with our email newsletterSign me up